At the peak of the body positivity years (circa 2016), I came across a video of a large woman kneeling on the ground, breaking a bathroom scale with a hammer. She said it was on behalf of women everywhere who were “ruled and ruined by it.” The comments were unkind. She had misplaced her anger, they said. She was shooting the messenger instead of addressing the problem her weight presented. She was clumsy with the hammer and very performative, so it did have an element of unintentional comedy to it. I laughed.

She was right. Scales are violent.


I was part of a competitive video game community for a while, and I grew my skills by building tools for it. One of them was LOOPR, the system behind a power rankings leaderboard. I wrote out the requirements I thought a good leaderboard should meet and built something that met all of them. It was good. It was great. It outperformed established rating systems like OpenSkill and Glicko-2, and when players were asked to rank each other blind, they agreed with it about 86% of the time.

The community rejected it anyway.

It started with enthusiastic support when I released a preview, players comparing where they ranked against each other and being happy about it. They’d see where their friends were and boast about it, dunk on each other, or be upset they weren’t on the power rankings yet. When the full service launched, however, the community ignored it.

Players had a habit they called “resulting”: they would essentially build resumes from their best wins, which led to a culture where stripping context was rewarded. The community hated it, but felt forced to participate. There were frequent posts saying “hey, we should use [LOOPR] to stop the ‘resulting’ culture.” Nothing changed.

I had an explanation ready. I called it the fat mirror problem: “this isn’t how I look, this must be a fat mirror.” Everyone agreed with the ranking until they found themselves in it.


Sociology calls what I did commensuration. It’s putting unlike things on a single common metric so they can be compared. A person becomes a weight. A player becomes a rating. And with comparison comes judgment.

Judgment is the point. A single number does something nothing else can: it puts everyone in order. Give me two people, and there are a hundred questions I’d ask to pick between them. Give me two numbers, and a child could choose. I don’t have to worry about nuance or context. It’s all on the scale. Everyone is ahead of someone and behind someone else.

That’s the attraction, and what causes the hurt. A single number is sharp enough to cut through noise, and sharp enough to cut people. Let’s start small.

The bench. I started going to the gym this year. Whenever I mention it, I immediately get hit with “what’s your bench?” It’s a friendly question, but it’s also a ranking one. It compresses everything I do there into a single value, so the person asking knows roughly where I belong. The benefit is small: it communicates where I am on my fitness journey in an instant. The cost is small too: I don’t have a number to give. (I don’t know my bench, I use machines. Sorry!)

The SAT. For a few years, the most elite colleges tried dropping the SAT. Test-optional was supposed to help the students the scale had been unfair to. The colleges have since reversed course. Dartmouth’s researchers found that disadvantaged applicants were holding back scores that would have helped them. The argument still isn’t over. Most colleges are still test-optional, and some critics say grades are better predictors while carrying less class and race bias. But that number is what lets a seventeen-year-old from La Joya, Texas, compete with one from La Jolla, California.

The credit score. Before scores, a loan officer decided whether you looked like the kind of person who pays his debts. Needless to say, black people in 1960s Alabama weren’t deemed trustworthy for reasons entirely unrelated to finance. Until a 1974 law, a single woman could be told to bring her father to co-sign. The score doesn’t know you. It lets a stranger lend to a stranger. Your ability to own a home no longer depends on whether a loan officer at your local bank likes the look of you. (When Congress asked the Federal Reserve to check how effective credit scores were at making credit more available, the best it could say was that scoring had “likely” widened access. Unfortunately, scoring was everywhere by then, and nobody could untangle it from everything else that had changed.)

The fact that you’re a stranger is also what cuts. The score can’t hear about the layoff or the hospital bill. Most bad marks stay on file for seven years. The number is used by the landlord and the insurance company. And if you don’t have a file at all, you might as well be invisible. It’s heavy to carry and yet still lighter than going without.

When we think of “scale,” though, we don’t really think about numbers that measure what you’ve done. We think about numbers that claim to measure what you are.

Height. Dating is hard and increasingly online. To help navigate a sea of people, the apps added preference filters. Height is right there, already a number. The benefit is modest: you set a filter and erase hundreds of people, narrowing down to find the right person for you. The cost isn’t. There are whole subreddits where shorter men talk about what height preferences have done to them. When researchers interviewed men from a similar support forum, the first thing they found was the belief that other people see short men as inferior. Hard to argue with when our vernacular frequently employs terms like “manlet.” The preference is strong enough that some economists worked out an exchange rate: a man who is 5‘6” needs about $175,000 more a year to do as well as one who is 6‘0”. And height is the one number here you can’t work on. Or rather, you couldn’t. More men are paying a surgeon upward of $70,000 to break their legs and stretch them a few inches. You can literally buy height now, and men are torturing their bodies to do it. The functional exchange rate became a literal one.

The scale. Doctors need your weight. Proper drug doses depend on it, and it gives a useful signal of health. In that room, the number earns its right to exist. In a bathroom, read alone every morning, the number cuts differently. Weight is the number we’re told we can change, so it becomes a judgment on your character. “You’re undisciplined. You’re lazy.” Even the kinder versions cut. “Are you depressed? Are you stressed?”

I don’t want to echo the body positivity movement. Obesity does kill, and normalizing it as a society does harm. Society started reversing course on body positivity the moment we had medication for obesity that worked. I think the focus on health is much better! But the judgment on character is brutal. That woman was in pain. The scale was not her target, it was simply the representative. She wasn’t shooting the messenger. She was shooting the ambassador.


Put these numbers next to each other and two patterns emerge. For numbers about what you’ve done, the benefit and the cost tend to climb together. How much I bench is barely useful and barely stings. My credit score can help me buy a house and keep me from renting an apartment. The more people we need to sort, the more we need the number, and the more it costs whoever it lands on. Herbert Simon put it best: “a wealth of information creates a poverty of attention.” A number is what we assign people we don’t have the attention to get to know.

The body works differently. Height and weight are visible from across the room. They’re unavoidable as measures; it would be weirder if we didn’t measure them. The problem is that by measuring, we commensurate. Once the number is there, it’s easy to use everywhere else. The cost climbs, the benefit doesn’t.

The artist says that reducing a person to a number is inhuman. The engineer scoffs: funny how the people who complain have low numbers.

I’ve been the engineer. And in writing this, I’m also the artist. I think they’re both kinda right. Something is being done to a person when they’re sorted. The very act of sorting is a little dehumanizing. But in a world full of strangers, sometimes we need the function provided by sorting anyway. And yes, the loudest objections tend to come from people ranked low. Why wouldn’t they? They’re screaming in pain.


Before LOOPR launched, I posted a preview, and someone sent me this:

curious how rankings are calced. mainly cause its super interesting to me and a little cause my ego cant handle being below some of these people

After the leaderboard was rejected, I took this message as proof. “Their egos couldn’t handle the truth. The mirror is a fat mirror.” In truth, I was trying to protect my ego. Someone was telling me what my number cost them, and I had the audacity to say they were wrong.

What had my number bought them? The community had a use for a ranking: resulting had grown so toxic that players were forgoing casual tournaments to avoid being resulted, an issue whose solution I baked into LOOPR. But that use belonged to the community as a whole, and the cost was paid by each person individually.

Commensuration is a socially violent act. It’s only tolerated if it earns its place, or if it’s unavoidable. The more it hurts, the more it has to justify its existence. The reason the use trends upwards with the cost is that any system where the two are imbalanced is killed off if it can be, as my leaderboard was. I built something far too violent for far too little benefit. These are people who poured big portions of their lives into their skill and built their identities on it.

The engineer’s instinct is more accuracy. A perfect ranking would have been worse: it would have been a stronger judgment on their identity. The problem was never that my number was wrong!

Tennis is a great example of what I should have built. The men’s rankings are points that are earned at tournaments, and each result falls out of the ranking window after fifty-two weeks. The rankings decide who gets into which events and who is seeded where, so they’re useful to the sport as a whole and to each player individually. They don’t pretend to peer into a player’s soul and extract their true tennis essence. Mine did.

The brilliance of the ATP’s design is that it gives players wiggle room. If your ATP ranking drops, you have several outs. I didn’t travel enough. I had that injury. I skipped that tournament to be with my wife. I had engineered that wiggle room out of mine. I accounted for everything I could think of, which meant nobody had a way to save face. The engineer in me wants to call those excuses coping. Most of them are true. The electric eye does not understand a bad day or where you’re headed, it just notes where you are without blinking.


I can’t see that video anymore without feeling the hurt she’s going through. The clumsiness reads differently to me now. It’s performative because she’s performing for herself. She couldn’t kill the measure, the best she could do was break the scale.

Part of medicine has landed on something sensible. Clinics that treat eating disorders still weigh their patients, because they have to. Treatment manuals say the patient should know the number, though this hasn’t been settled with a study. About half of clinicians do it blind anyway. The patient steps on the scale facing backwards and isn’t told the number. They kept the measurement, and removed the patient from the commensuration.

As Thomas Sowell once put it, there are no solutions, only trade-offs. I tried to build a messenger that delivered the truth about players’ souls; I built an ambassador instead. It deserved to be killed.